Saturday, November 12, 2016

Copyright Clarity

My notes while reading Copyright Clarity

When I started as a Loudoun Creates member last year, one of our first sessions was all about copyright for when we started producing media with our students.   We heard the educational use guidelines version of only use 30 seconds of a song, try to find public domain or creative commons work, and only use 10% of a work.  In my classroom, I fell under the category of teacher who used what I wanted when I wanted, but didn’t share it with others for fear of copyright infringement. 

How refreshing was it to read that there is a plethora of ways I can use copyrighted materials, share them with parents, teachers, and other students, and be protected under Fair Use.  Fair Use is concerned with the transformativeness of the work.  How has the original been used to create something new and different in purpose and perhaps audience?  There are 4 categories typically considered for judging fair use:
-How does the purpose of the new work compare with the original?
-What is the nature of the material?
-What is the scope of the original product that has been used?
-Will the new creation impact the market for the original?

In education, I think most of the time, we are safe under Fair Use using these judgments.  Rarely are we using materials for the same purpose as the original, nor are we taking profits away from the creator.  Depending on the project, most of the time, educators and our students use bits and pieces of intellectual property to create something entirely different and new.  What we need to do as educators is be evaluative.  We need to think about our use of copyrighted materials and make a judgment using the ideas of fair use. 


When I taught my first DDLS designed unit on architects, one of my background building activities was for my kiddos to look at the architecture and shapes in a picture of a building, and copy that with paper shapes to their math journals.  It was a great activity and they were using the geometry standard to find shapes in the environment and draw those shapes on paper.  I wanted to share the activity with parents via Twitter, but I was hesitant.  Without the original photo, the context of the lesson would be lost.  In fact, I did share each individual creation with parents separately, but they had a hard time understanding what the students had actually accomplished without the original reference.  Thinking now with Fair Use, the photo originally came from a website that provides high definition images of various home style inspirations for free.  There is no market impact.  The original purpose was to provide inspiration – we used it as such, but our new purpose would be as a reference to our own creations.  I only used one image from the site, so used a very small scope of the originator’s work.  I would feel comfortable sharing my students’ creations now that I have a more thorough understanding of copyright, and can go forward with confidence to make those decisions in the future.

4 comments:

  1. I enjoyed reading your last paragraph when you talk about your first DDLS-designed lesson and the issue of fair use that you pondered during the unit. It was helpful to read your thought process as you went through the four main questions Hobbs suggested as you thought about using the images under fair use. I also thought about your Pecha Kucha and how you said you second-guessed yourself and included the source of each image. I have also been second-guessing myself. I think we have been ingrained with false or skewed information about copyright and fair use for so long, it’s going to take practice to break the cycle of assuming we’re doing something “wrong.”

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is unfortunate the misconceptions that we have been fed over our lifetimes. Until I read this book, I honestly believed that we were only allowed to use a limited amount of video or audio in our students projects. Which is why I used to be like you and be one of those teachers that would close their door, and do what I wanted and not have them share. I can't wait to go back to my classroom and team and share what I learned.
    Also, I agree with you. As teachers, I feel we are usually covered under fair use. Since we almost never use things in the same way as they were originally intended. It's one of our skills as teachers. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yay! So glad you feel more comfortable sharing projects through twitter now. I bet you can repeat the project next year sharing it via twitter and it will be a big hit again.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Love your image of your notes :) And totally agree that you could share the inspiration image under fair use! Great example. Also, I totally agree that the Loudoun Creates session made me feel like copyright put me in a box but our conversations in class have made me feel more free.

    ReplyDelete