Sunday, October 30, 2016

The Information Diet

There is an overwhelming amount of information available to us and to our students these days.  Not only do we need to know how to sift through it all ourselves, but it has also become our job to help our students navigate this as well.  How do we know what is worthwhile, true, and helpful?

This makes me think of Pinterest and Teachers Pay Teachers.  I’ve gone on my binges with both sites, but I do try to be very cautious when searching for materials.  I do know some teachers who will go to these sites and just pick them because they look cute or seem like something related to what they are aiming to teach.  The problem here is that with the majority of the country on Common Core, those of us teaching in Virginia have different standards to teach AND the content produced on these sites is not monitored by anyone saying it is aligned to standards as it should be. When I do use these sites, I have a clear idea in mind about what I am looking to achieve and don’t go blindly looking for “resources on X.”

I know, too well, the time sink that can happen browsing the internet.  I have lost days to catching up on web comics, going page by page through entertaining websites, scrolling and scrolling through Facebook, and trying to sift through information for personal or professional research.  It’s a pretty daunting task to have to help students to develop the skills to manage this world of unlimited information and distraction. 


While I don’t see myself, as a first grade teacher, directly teaching sorting through all the information muck on the internet, I can, however, help them develop the skills using other sources of information.  I can help my students develop the skills to sort and judge, search, create, communicate, and synthesize information in a way that is developmentally appropriate.  Then, when they get to higher grades and they are researching for a project, they will already have a base for those skills.

Tuesday, October 25, 2016

Design Principle #6 Students as Designers


Good learning designs engage students in using content to construct meaningful outcomes by comprehensively scaffolding students’ ability to design.

We need to give students the opportunities to create and design, just like we do.  They need to use what they learn to build something, manipulate information, sort through information.  Bloom’s Taxonomy puts creating at the very top of the higher order thinking skills; it’s not enough to know the content, students need to be able to use the information as a tool and do something with it.

Students need to express their creativity without too many constraints put on them.  When we put their work into a neat little box with lots of rules, there aren’t many options for our students to stretch, explore, and grow. 

I have a student this year who definitely marches to her own drum.  She was getting ready to publish a story and brought it to me to staple the pages together.  The pages were all in the right order but on the back side of the page.  When I tried to tell her that she should flip the pages around she insisted that it was exactly how she wanted it.  She designed it that way, and here I was trying to fit her back into a nice neat box.  I decided to let her do it her way, because it didn’t really matter.  When I think about it, some of the more interesting books don’t follow conventional physical structure. 

I’ve started an adventure with my first graders using my lesson design that we did for class.  I’m having them think and work like architects.  One of the activities I had them do was to evaluate different shapes for different parts of a house.  I had them first think about the purpose of a roof on a house.  They gave me all the inside-the-box answers that I was “looking” for such as to keep rain and snow out, to keep bugs and other pests out, and protect us from tornados.   After getting “tornados” three times in a row, I was calling on my last student, eager to move on with the lesson, she said something that completely altered the course of my lesson. 

“We need a roof on the house so Santa can land there.” 

Her suggestion led my class to think critically about the roof shapes – which was my goal – yet in a completely different way than I had anticipated.  It didn’t take away from the discussions centered around “real” concerns for home building, it added to it and it was a “real” concern for my six-year-olds.  Sometimes, I think we get so bogged down into what we have planned for students to “discover” that we don’t let them think for themselves – it can be pretty amazing.

Sunday, October 16, 2016

Affordance Analysis & Design Principle #5

Technologies have certain features that they allow the user to use or do.  They change the way the user interacts with the world.  What they offer the user depends on the technology and can be very different.  What the technology provides the user is called an affordance.  There are many different categories of affordances.

We need to choose the right tool for the job.  You could use a screwdriver to hammer in a nail, but it wouldn’t do a really good job of it.  A hammer is much more suited for the job.  Luckily for the carpenter, many of his or her tools are specifically designed for a specific purpose.  Unluckily for us teachers, many of the tools we have the opportunity to use were not designed for our tasks or our learners.  To work around this, we need to do an affordance analysis when thinking about the technology tools to use in the classroom.  To do this we go through a process and ask the following questions:
  • ·       What are the learning goals?  What is it that I want my students to be learning?
  • ·       What will the students be doing to demonstrate this learning?
  • ·       What does the technology tool need to offer students to demonstrate learning?
  • ·       What do the available tools offer the user?
  • ·       How does what the tool needs to do match up with what the tool offers?

This can lead us to make the most informed decision on which tool will be the best fit for the job.  Following an affordance analysis is one more aspect of good learning design and is demonstrated in the fifth design principle:
Good learning designs reflect technologies chosen after mindful consideration of the cognitive and societal consequences as well as a clear and appropriate connection with content and learning activities. 

In schools, we are often provided a range of technology tools that we then get to figure out how to best use in our practice.  We also have increasingly more “free” options available to us.  Everyone is keen to share these new and wonderful technology tools, but it is our job to analyze these tools to figure out what they can do for us and our students and how that matches up with what we need our students to do.  It’s not enough to use the newest up and coming technology just because it’s new.  There’s nothing wrong with using it if it is the right choice. 


I often lean on Wixie for my students to show their learning in the classroom.  After doing an affordance analysis on what Wixie offers, it makes a lot of sense – the tool does a lot for what my students need to accomplish.  My first graders need to manipulate objects, write, draw, record their voices, and listen to prerecorded directions.  What I need to be careful of, is not falling back to this tool for everything and really evaluating other technologies that could do more for my students with a given task.

Tuesday, October 11, 2016

The Victorian Internet


New technologies always have similar, if not the exact same, consequences.   This applies to older technologies and newer ones as well.  The Victorian Internet chronicles the changes and challenges brought about surrounding the invention of the telegraph.  Endless parallels can be drawn between the consequences of the antiquated telegraph and the more modern invention of the internet. 

There are various other consequences of new technologies.  New technology is very expensive at first and is only available generally to the very rich and government and typically goes through a diffusion process before it is widely accepted and used by the masses.  When this happens, the pace of life characteristically speeds up and regulations can’t keep up with the use of the new technology.  This may also cause job responsibilities to change and a shift in the structure of authority.

One thing that stuck out at me the most is that technologies are not inherently good or evil; they are completely dependent on human nature.  There are people who will use technology for good, and others who will find ways to use technology for bad.  People have used both the telegraph and the internet to scheme others out of money, to cheat systems, and steal information.  On the other hand, there are always those out there to enhance communication, form positive relationship, and improve the lives of others.

As we introduce technologies to students, it’s important to keep these in mind.  We are often adapting technology originally designed for military and government to be operated by users who fit a much different profile.  Even with the best guidelines, there will be students who use technology in ways in which we don’t approve.  Additionally, we need to prepare them to protect themselves against those who would harm them if given the opportunity. 

Tuesday, October 4, 2016

Design Principle #4 - The Learning Principle

Good learning designs engage students in “playful” activities at the edge of their knowledge and understanding using symbolic tools to develop and internalize meaningful thought.

As we design our lessons, we need to approach them in a way that is between what students can learn on their own and what they can learn with our help (the zone of proximal development).  It is during this part that we do the coaching in the modeling, coaching, fading progression.  As the students use the symbolic tools (the language and written structure) in this guided structure, they start to internalize the tools and then can start to be able to use and understand them independently.

Before this week, I was discussing with a colleague (who went through the program before the name was changed to DooDLES) about everything we were learning and especially situated cognition.  We were discussing what that looks like in first grade – how do I get my tiny wonders to enculturate to the discipline we are learning in.  We discussed that it might look like “Today we are going to be doctors – we are going to think and act and learn like doctors today.”  After this week, with Vygotsky’s emphasis on play, this model continues to align with the design principles.  As they “play” at being doctors (or whichever discipline we are enculturated in) they will use the discourse and knowledge as tools for their learning.  All of the different puzzle pieces are starting to come together.

This school year I set out to structure my schedule in order to give my class more breaks, more movement, and more opportunities to be just be kids.  As I worked through the time requirements for various subjects, I was left without having those “be a kid” breaks that I had desired.  I want them to have more opportunities to play, explore, and be six/seven-year-olds.  I’m hoping that pretending to be different professionals will help make “work time” feel more playful.  I actually had a group of students naturally exhibit play in a school setting.  They were in our library center and they decided to “pretend to be librarians.”  This led them to come up with the “rules” that they needed to be very careful with the books and be incredibly quiet.  This led the next group at that center to also want to be librarians and were equally productive and calm.


I often tell my students that they need to treat their materials as tools, not toys.  I tell them frequently not to play, that this is work time.  I’m having trouble reconciling Vygotsky’s purposeful learning play with the sometimes frivolous play my students engage in such as using markers as swords when we are supposed to be using them for the purpose of writing.  How do I encourage the “right kind” of play?  Maybe in that exact situation, we discuss the “rules” writers use like how they use their tools.  Writers use their tools for writing, not for swordplay.