Sunday, October 16, 2016

Affordance Analysis & Design Principle #5

Technologies have certain features that they allow the user to use or do.  They change the way the user interacts with the world.  What they offer the user depends on the technology and can be very different.  What the technology provides the user is called an affordance.  There are many different categories of affordances.

We need to choose the right tool for the job.  You could use a screwdriver to hammer in a nail, but it wouldn’t do a really good job of it.  A hammer is much more suited for the job.  Luckily for the carpenter, many of his or her tools are specifically designed for a specific purpose.  Unluckily for us teachers, many of the tools we have the opportunity to use were not designed for our tasks or our learners.  To work around this, we need to do an affordance analysis when thinking about the technology tools to use in the classroom.  To do this we go through a process and ask the following questions:
  • ·       What are the learning goals?  What is it that I want my students to be learning?
  • ·       What will the students be doing to demonstrate this learning?
  • ·       What does the technology tool need to offer students to demonstrate learning?
  • ·       What do the available tools offer the user?
  • ·       How does what the tool needs to do match up with what the tool offers?

This can lead us to make the most informed decision on which tool will be the best fit for the job.  Following an affordance analysis is one more aspect of good learning design and is demonstrated in the fifth design principle:
Good learning designs reflect technologies chosen after mindful consideration of the cognitive and societal consequences as well as a clear and appropriate connection with content and learning activities. 

In schools, we are often provided a range of technology tools that we then get to figure out how to best use in our practice.  We also have increasingly more “free” options available to us.  Everyone is keen to share these new and wonderful technology tools, but it is our job to analyze these tools to figure out what they can do for us and our students and how that matches up with what we need our students to do.  It’s not enough to use the newest up and coming technology just because it’s new.  There’s nothing wrong with using it if it is the right choice. 


I often lean on Wixie for my students to show their learning in the classroom.  After doing an affordance analysis on what Wixie offers, it makes a lot of sense – the tool does a lot for what my students need to accomplish.  My first graders need to manipulate objects, write, draw, record their voices, and listen to prerecorded directions.  What I need to be careful of, is not falling back to this tool for everything and really evaluating other technologies that could do more for my students with a given task.

4 comments:

  1. Alissa...I had never heard of Wixie. Do you think it is appropriate for fourth graders, or is it better suited for younger ages? I agree about getting used to using our favorite go to technology and possibly not opening ourselves up to new ideas. Our school just had professional development on Genius Hour from Google. You might want to check it out. It starts out with I Wonder statements and kids turn it into a project throughout the year. It's interesting. I have so much going on right now with projects, I may have to wait until next year.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Learning about affordances analysis made me breathe a sigh of relief in one sense because it made me realize I don't need to beat myself up for not using the latest technology. Like you said, we can't use technology just because it's new. We need to decide if it's helping the learning goal. That being said, we can't just rely on an old stand-by technology tool because it's important to mix-up technology just like we mix up how we teach learning goals to students.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alissa,
    You had a great comparison with the usefulness of using a screwdriver, as a hammer, would it work...maybe, but it certainly wouldn’t be as effective. I couldn’t help but laugh when you mentioned how unlike a carpenter we are unlucky, because our “tools” are very rarely designed to work in the classroom. It’s a sad but true reality. We are often left with the daunting task of trying to see if these great technologies, designed for other purposes can be re-purposed for education.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love your screwdriver/hammer analogy--it really makes the point clear. I giggled at how unlucky we are as educators with the tools we have :) But you are so right and it is just another thing that makes our profession unique and presents us with its own challenges. I definitely agree that Wixie is an easy go to for creating things and that it's easy to fall into the trap of always relying on that technology. I think for me, it stuck in my mind because it was pushed so frequently by people above me that I held onto it. But, I know there are lots of other options out there for other purposes that might be better tools for a certain project, we just need to find them. For example, Wixie could be used to make a thinking web but there is another tool called Popplet that allows you to do the same thing but ALSO have the whole class on it, collaborating on the same thing. I think that offers a totally different experience and purpose than Wixie even though it's just a small change to the technology.

    ReplyDelete